383 Broadway, Mid Cambridge

View of 383 Broadway from the mid-1960s. CHC.

Today we’re featuring 383 Broadway in Mid Cambridge. The original house on the lot was built by John J. Bright, a founder of the Boston Ice Company, who lived there until 1911 when he moved to Brookline. Bright’s mansion was demolished in 1917.

1916 Bromley map showing property of John J. Bright. The residence was razed in 1917. CHC.

The present house at 383 Broadway was built in 1922 and designed by the Cambridge architect Edward Graham. One of Graham’s first major commissions was the 1907 Shoe and Leather Exposition Building near Kendall Square, which contained the largest auditorium in New England. During his long career, Graham designed a number of institutional and ecclesiastical buildings such as the Lincoln School, St. Mary’s Hall on Prospect Street, St. Mary’s School on Essex Street, and the Nurses’ Home at Cambridge Hospital. Other residences by the designer include 16 Francis Street, 61 Fayette Street, and Jefferson Park apartments.

1930 Bromley map showing 383 Broadway. CHC.
Portrait of Dr. Herbert Cronin from an article in the May 13, 1916, Cambridge Chronicle announcing his appointment as the physician tending Cambridge City employees injured on the job.

Graham designed the house Drs. Herbert and Anastasia Cronin and their two children and included an office and work space. Herbert was a physician and treated Cambridge municipal employees under the Workingmen’s Compensation Act; he was also the factory physician for Boston Woven Hose and Rubber Company. Anastasia, a graduate of Tufts Dental School, practiced dentistry in Inman Square and specialized in orthodontia. She was also the dentist at the Women’s Reformatory in Sherborn (now MCI-Framingham). Their house included a separate entrance on Maple Avenue that led directly to Herbert’s first floor office and waiting room. On the second floor Anastasia had her own lab room for her dentistry work. The Colonial Revival-style house features a hipped roof, narrow cornice, wood clapboard siding (now aluminum siding), and a prominent central entrance. 

Architect’s drawing showing elevation with main entrance facing Broadway. Cambridge Inspectional Services.
Architect’s drawing of elevation facing Maple Avenue with entrance to Herbert’s office. Cambridge Inspectional Services.
Architect’s floor plan showing Dr. Herbert Cronin’s first floor office and waiting room. Cambridge Inspectional Services.
Architect’s floor plan showing the dental room designed for Dr. Anastasia Cronin. Cambridge Inspectional Services.

Anastasia tragically died from an illness soon after they moved into the house. At about the same time, Herbert lost his eyesight and could no longer perform surgeries. He later married Dr. Elizabeth Ann Sullivan, a friend of Anastasia’s who also worked at the Reformatory. She persuaded Herbert to become a psychiatrist and helped him with his training to become certified. They continued to live at 383 Broadway and maintain their practices on site. Elizabeth also devoted herself to helping those in need. She employed women newly released from the Reformatory at her home to help them get a fresh start and volunteered as physician at The Cambridge Homes for Aged People located across the street from the house. In the 1930s Elizabeth provided free medical care to women who had emigrated to the city from Austria and Germany and helped them navigate their new lives. Her children remember that a Linzer torte was delivered to her every Christmas as a thank you from the women she helped. Elizabeth also directed the Cambridge chapter of the Red Cross and opened the Red Cross Central Square unit for blood donations during WWII. Elizabeth passed away in 1955, and Herbert followed four years later.

Portrait of Dr. Elizabeth Ann Sullivan. Cambridge Historical Society.

The house was later home to Anna and Wiktor Weintraub, Polish refugees who arrived in the U.S. in the mid-1950s. During WWII, Anna, a doctor, had been the director of the Polish Hospital in Jerusalem. Wiktor served the Polish Government-in-Exile as information officer in its embassies in Moscow, Jerusalem, and London.  Wiktor was a historian who specialized in the history of Polish literature and taught Slavic studies at Harvard; in 1971 he became the Alfred Jurzykowski Professor Emeritus of Polish Language and Literature. Anna died in 1967, and Wiktor married the scholar Maria Evelina Zoltowska in 1974. On Wiktor’s death in 1988, the New York Times noted his accomplishments as a prolific writer in both English and Polish. His last book, The Poet and the Prophet, was published in 1982.

Photograph of Witkor Weintraub, https://tinyurl.com/y3yy6zgn
View of 383 Broadway today. CHC.

Cambridge Historical Society, https://cambridgehistory.org/research/did-you-know/elizabeth-ann-sullivan-m-d/

Dr. Anastasia Cronin, Cambridge Chronicle, January 5, 1924.

Dr. Herbert Cronin, Cambridge Chronicle, May 13, 1916.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wiktor_Weintraub

https://timesmachine.nytimes.com/timesmachine/1988/07/16/044288.html?pageNumber=33

https://ruj.uj.edu.pl/xmlui/bitstream/handle/item/11040/pietrzyk_wiktor_weintraub_1908-1988_2014.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y

A History of Holy Ghost Hospital (Spaulding Hospital)

Today we are profiling the former Holy Ghost Hospital at 1575 Cambridge Street — later Youville Hospital, and now the Spaulding Hospital for Continuing Medical Care Cambridge, a multi-building campus, part of the Spaulding Rehabilitation Network.

Front of postcard reads “This is where I am staying, 10 min walk from Harvard.” CHC Postcard Collection.

The Holy Ghost Hospital for Incurables was established around 1893-1894 by Cambridge’s Reverend Thomas Scully and the Sisters of Charity of Montreal (the “Grey Nuns”), an order founded by St. Marguerite d’Youville in 1737. The hospital was founded on St. Marguerite’s vision to care for patients “regardless of their race, religion, or ability to pay,” along with the Reverend Scully’s dream of a hospital that would serve those with chronic illness and disabilities. 

St. Marguerite d’Youville, diocesemontreal.org

Scully chose the name Holy Ghost after the Sancto Spiritu Hospital in Rome, which he had visited as a student in that city.  Scully deeded six acres of land for the new hospital at Cambridge Street and Hovey Avenue, previously the Hovey estate.

From Cambridge Hopkins Atlas, 1886, Mapjunction.com.

In 1894 the hospital welcomed their first patient to their first facility, a partially completed 24-bed “cottage” designed by W.H. and J.A. McGinty. In this first year, the Grey Nuns cared for 12 patients at a time.   In 1895 construction began on a 75-bed, four-story brick and stone building to replace the cottage (the cottage was razed in 1949). Officially dedicated in 1898, the new building was U-shaped with a projecting center pavilion, and featured quoins, window surrounds, and trim in Indiana limestone. It also featured a chapel, which until the early 2000s held regular Mass for its patients. 

A prospectus of 1896 in “The Catholic Church of New England” reads that the hospital site is:

“happily located on Cambridge Street, in the very heart of Cambridge, and contains about 6 acres of beautiful land, upon which are many handsome elm trees, which add greatly to the scenery…The main building will be of brick, with stone and terra cotta trimmings, and slated roof, and will be fireproof, and in every respect modern. In this building will be the reception rooms, dispensary, rooms for medical staff and chaplain, and other offices. The administration building, with its adjoining wards, will be built well back toward the rear of the lot…leaving the open space in front of the administration building for drives, walks, lawns, fountains, and flowers.”

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is MC_P016_12.jpg
Holy Ghost Hospital, Cambridge Photo Morgue Collection, digitized by Digital Commonwealth. The image is estimated as taken between 1920-1924 but it could have been earlier.

Multiple additions were made to the hospital campus over the years, including a carriage shed and stable in 1901 and 1903; nurses dormitory in 1905; balconies in 1911; hospital laundry and a five-story addition in 1924; a west wing in 1927, which would add 90 patient beds; and many additions and alterations between 1941 and 1997, including a new nurses dormitory and an east wing. These later additions would obscure the original building and today it is hard to imagine the original structures.

Holy Ghost Hospital under construction, January 5, 1927.
Nurses posing with an artistic fountain presented to the Holy Ghost Hospital for Incurables, Cambridge, by James J. Conley, a director in the Harvard Trust Company. June 25, 1929. Cambridge Photo Morgue Collection, digitized by Digital Commonwealth.

The hospital was active during major health emergencies in Cambridge, including the 1918-1919 Influenza epidemic.

“How Cambridge is Fighting the Grippe,” Cambridge Chronicle, October 12, 1918.

The CHC holds a small collection of photographs from the family of Claire Lawrence Levesque, a nurse’s aide at Holy Ghost Hospital during the 1920s and 1930s. Not much is known about Levesque’s time at the hospital, but her photos give a personal glimpse into life there in the 1920s (most of the photos are before the addition of the new wing in 1926-1927). 

Unidentified nurse or nurse’s aide, possibly Claire Levesque?, undated. Levesque Collection, CHC.
Three women, likely Sisters, standing in front of the base of a statue on the grounds of the Holy Ghost Hospital, undated. Photo verso reads “Sr. Delia Carrier.” Levesque Collection, CHC.
Eight unidentified nurses and patients, easternmost front entrance of Holy Ghost Hospital, undated. Levesque Collection, CHC.

In 1947 the hospital opened a cancer research unit, and in 1952 they opened an inpatient and outpatient rehabilitation unit. In 1953 Dr. Charles Bonner joined the hospital staff as a cancer researcher with an interest in rehabilitation. Bonner, a former Boston University School of Medicine professor, was also one of the first African-American graduates of the school, and he would become a leader in the rehabilitation field.

In 1959 the Cardinal Cushing Rehabilitation Center opened at the hospital, and in 1970 the hospital joined the Covenant Health Systems and was re-dedicated as Youville Hospital & Rehabilitation Center, a 305-bed care facility for elders and those in need of rehabilitation. 

Aerial view showing the Holy Ghost campus, 1947. Patriquin Collection, CHC.

In 2001 Youville Hospital joined with Spaulding Rehabilitation Hospital, and in 2009 Spaulding purchased Youville, officially changing the hospital’s name to Spaulding Hospital Cambridge.  Today, in addition to their site in Cambridge, Spaulding Hospital has sites in Brighton, Medford, Malden, Boston, and beyond. Their Cambridge location continues to serve as a certified long-term acute care hospital and an outpatient rehabilitation center. They are the home of innovative research programs of the Spaulding Rehabilitation Network, including the Cardiovascular Research Lab, Exercise for Persons with Disabilities (ExPD), the Spaulding National Running Center, and the INSPIRE Lab for Sensorimotor Rehabilitation & Engineering Technologies. The campus also includes Youville House at 1573 Cambridge St, an assisted living residence established in 1998.

Spaulding Hospital for Continuing Medical Care Cambridge

In December 2020, the City of Cambridge announced that they would be leasing space at Spaulding Hospital for the new Transition Wellness Center (TWC), a temporary (24 months) 58-bed emergency homeless shelter for adults who test negative for COVID-19. Residents from the shelter at the War Memorial Recreation Center would be transitioned to TWC. The City-funded TWC is located on the first and second floors of the east wing of Spaulding, which were previously vacant (the rest of this wing has been used largely for equipment storage rather than patient care for many years).  In the beginning of the pandemic in March, Spaulding’s fourth floor of this building also served as a recovery center for COVID-19 patients. 

Spaulding’s East Wing, site of the TWC

For more information on the evolution of the hospital over the years, including a historical pamphlet and photographs, please contact us at chcarchives@cambridgema.gov.

Sources:

CHC survey file, 1575 Cambridge Street

“Celebrating the Generations 1895-1995,” Youville Hospital & Rehabilitation Center pamphlet, CHC Library.

Boston’s Hidden Sacred Spaces: http://www.hiddensacredspaces.org/spaulding-rehabilitation-hospital-chapel-and-meditation-room-cambridge

Spaulding Hospital: https://spauldingrehab.org/locations/cambridge-continuing-medical-care 

Torn Down Tuesday: 329 Harvard Street

Welcome back to our Torn Down Tuesday series! Today, we are featuring the house that once stood at 329 Harvard Street in Mid-Cambridge.

Detail of 1886 Cambridge Hopkins Atlas

In December 1848, George Washington Whittemore (1812-1870) purchased a lot from the Francis Dana estate. The lot was situated on the north side of Harvard Street between Cotton (now Hancock) and Dana Streets and backed on Hastings (now Chatham) street. The Whittemore family was prominent in the business and cultural life of Boston and Cambridge: George W. had many business ventures and was most notably a Boston hotel proprietor. After the home was finished, George W. moved in with his wife, Synia H. (Richardson), on July 8, 1850.

Photograph c. 1865 showing house, stable, and grounds

Originally richly ornamented, this suburban house blended Italianate, Greek Revival, and Gothic details in an eclectic but picturesque and singularly harmonious manner. The house typified a trend away from the strict neo-classicism of around 1850. The house was originally remarkable for extensive use of exterior papier mâché ornament. The front and side eaves of the main block, and the cupola (measuring 8′ in diameter) were trimmed with molded papier mâché “gingerbread” mounted on wooden barge boards, until they were destroyed in an accidental fire from painter’s blow-torch in 1931. The cupola retained its trim at least as late as 1951. In its eclectic design, the house was typical of suburban residences built on Dana Hill c. 1850, when formal Greek Revival tradition was yielding to freer Italianate forms and more picturesque massing.

329 Harvard St photographed by Walker Evans, ca. 1930-31. © Walker Evans Archive, The Metropolitan Museum of Art

To enter the home from Harvard Street, one would approach the front steps: five granite risers flanked by granite plinths led to a granite stoop recessed within an open rectangular front entrance. A round-arched front doorway was deeply recessed within the stoop and sheltered by a balcony.

Entrance photographed by Jack E. Baucher (August 1964)

Inside, single-paneled pilasters with 1′-high plinths and gessoed papier mâché Greek Corinthian capitals flanked all drawing room openings and “supported” plaster entabulature.

Interior pilaster detail photographed by Jack E. Baucher (August 1964)

The original interior of the home was highly lavish and Victorian. Red flocked drawing room wallpaper with cream and gilt ground dated from 1850 and remained to the end of the Whittemore occupancy. The drawing room also had original richly-colored imported carpet, red velvet lambrequins with gilded cornices, and a set of very elaborate neo-rococo furniture inspired by Louis XV forms.

Interior of 329 Harvard St photographed by Richard Ruggles, 1937 (for D.P. Myer)

The set included two white marble-topped tables, a mirrored étagère with a low marble-topped console, and chairs, sofa and footstool upholstered in original red velvet. According to family records, the curtain cornices and furniture were made by a group of travelling Swiss artisans skilled in comp work and frame making.

Interior of 329 Harvard St photographed by Richard Ruggles, 1937 (for D.P. Myer)

Marble busts of Hiram Powers’ Persephone and the Apollo Belvedere, a plaster bust of Washington, two oval family portraits of young girls ca. 1850, an oil copy of Guido Reni’s Aurora, alabaster vases, parian ware figurines, and a multitude of bibelots (a small, decorative ornament or trinket) completed the lavish drawing room ensemble, which remained intact until 1949.

Interior of 329 Harvard St photographed by Richard Ruggles, 1937 (for D.P. Myer)

A significant modernization of the house was undertaken in 1922-23 where a coal-fired hot air heating replaced the oil-fired steam system, the flooring was updated, electric lights and a laundry room were installed, among many other amenities. The home continued to be passed down to successive Whittemores until is was sold out of family in June 1951. The house changed hands several times from 1962-1964, by which time the structure had badly deteriorated. Finally, the house was demolished in 1965 to clear site for the Dana Hill Apartments. To learn more about this building, check out yesterday’s Modern Monday Instagram post!

329 Harvard St photographed by Roger Gilman, ca. 1930s

Source: Historic American Buildings Survey (HABS) report by Dr. Bainbridge Bunting (1964)

Cambridgeport Burial Ground (now Sennott Park)

This text was adapted from our Instagram post on 10/14/2020.

Did you know that Sennott Park (Broadway and Norfolk Street) is located on the site of the former Cambridgeport Burial Ground? This has also been referred to as the Broadway Cemetery and Ward II Burial Ground.

Sennott Park

The burial ground was active from 1811/1812 to about 1865. At the time of the its establishment, Cambridgeport was being settled as a district of the city, with the hope of eventually incorporating as a separate city (!). With this in mind, Cambridgeport citizens laid out a town center between Norfolk and Columbia streets, with the burial ground adjacent. 

In 1846, the superintendent of the grounds, Daniel Stone, reported that since its opening there had been an estimated 2500-2600 burials and 30 tombs that were taken up by two or more families. The burial ground was discontinued after 1865, and the graves were excavated and the remains transferred to the present Cambridge Cemetery or to another cemetery selected by the family of the deceased. 

By the 1870s, the area had been landscaped as a public square and renamed Broadway Park. It was re-landscaped in 1894 by the Olmsted firm, and renamed Edward J. Sennott Park in 1939 after a late City Councillor.

Burial Ground Lot, Ward II – Park plans, 1868

The park was redesigned in 1969 as part of the Model Cities program and again in the early 1970s. It remains a highly active public park, and the City has plans to make repairs and modest improvements to the park beginning in spring 2021 (according to their last website update).

The Cambridge Historical Commission has two original plot maps of the burial ground from the Engineering Department, shown below.

The image above is a plot plan for the “Strangers’ Lot,” so-called because this large lot in the northwest corner of the grounds was “reserved for the burial of paupers and strangers” (Lucius Paige, History of Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1630-1877). Superintendent Stone reported that the lot had been buried over “and commenced the second time” by 1846. Stone also wrote that during a Strangers’ Lot burial in 1826, diggers came upon “an ancient Indian fireplace… . That part of town being, according to appearance, formerly a great place for Indian resort.”

The second image, above, is dated 1902 and depicts the then-remaining plots in the “Central Passage” of the burial ground.

You will see names crossed off in both of these plot maps. We speculate that this was done as remains were transferred to other cemeteries in the years after 1865; the same may have happened after the second redesign in 1894. 

Cambridge Chronicle, May 7, 1970

It seems that not enough care was taken during the initial process of transferring remains–over the years headstones have been found in house foundations around the neighborhood, and in 1970 fragmentary human remains were discovered at the site of a playground under construction on the park.

For information on other cemeteries in Cambridge, including research on the Old Burying Ground in Harvard Square, check out an earlier post here.

The 1918-1919 Flu Epidemic Comes Home

 The United States entered the Great War on April 6, 1917. Thousands of Americans were trained and sent overseas, where they mixed with military personnel and civilians from Europe, Africa, and western Asia, creating an ideal environment for the spread of influenza. The first wave of the epidemic struck Europe in the spring of 1918. Demobilized servicemen carried the disease back to Boston, where the deadly second wave began in early September.

Hundreds of sailors in training at the Navy’s Harvard Radio School were billeted in college halls and in temporary barracks on Cambridge Common; they mingled freely with locals and went on day trips to nearby tourist spots. On September 8, alarmed by the high number of cases, Navy medical personnel placed the school under a 10-day quarantine. By then the epidemic had spread into civilian Cambridge.

Young sailors, students at the navy’s radio training school, lounge by the barracks on Cambridge Common and admire the statue of John Bridge. At right is the Harvard Epworth Methodist Episcopal Church on Massachusetts Avenue.

Mayor Edward Quinn vowed to turn the city into a “disease fighting machine.” City schools were closed–“some 3,400 students were reported ill … nearly a quarter of the total enrollment” (Cambridge, Massachusetts, and the 1918-1919 Influenza Epidemic, http://www.influenzaarchive/org). Church services and lodge meetings were banned and soda fountains, ice cream parlors, pool rooms, bowling alleys, billiard halls, and public auction rooms shuttered. Everyone wore masks.

Mayor Edward Quinn responded swiftly and with determination to protect Cambridge citizens from the epidemic.

There was a city-wide shortage of doctors, nurses, and hospital beds; cases multiplied too quickly to count. District and Visiting Nurses were dispatched wherever needed; residents “offered their automobiles and services as operators to get them about. During the next five weeks, from September 25, [the nurses] made 2,527 calls.”

A masked squad of Visiting Nurses gather in front of their headquarters at
35 Bigelow Street. The Cambridge VNA was established in 1904.

On September 27, the Board of Health declared a public emergency, which enabled them to commandeer the Merrill School and convert it, room by room, into an emergency hospital for the seriously ill. Initially, no “nurses or doctors could be found in the usual way and we had to depend on volunteers. It is greatly to the credit of many married women who had been trained in hospital, and to the schoolteachers unoccupied … who cheerfully volunteered their services [and] gave up their homes to assist in this emergency. Others who could not do nursing volunteered for other duty [such as clerks, organizers, and supply managers] and the firemen also gave their days off to assist as the hospital.”

Merrill Elementary School at 2 Fayette Street (present site of the Longfellow School).

By early October every classroom was in use and every bed (more than 105) occupied. The Massachusetts State Guard erected a dozen tents in the school yard, and influenza patients who had developed pneumonia were moved there.

The Red Cross supplied beds, linens, towels, and surgical aprons and donated “all food which may be needed for patients and nurses and again all medicines and drugs.” Navy physicians served with doctors from other parts of the country that had been dispatched to Cambridge by the state health department.

Cambridge citizens rallied, including Mr. J. Frank Facey, chair of the Committee on Public Safety, who neglected his own printing business to arrange transport for people and supplies, including food stuffs. The Cambridge Neighborhood House on Moore Street became a food distribution center, and Alice Moore, the head worker, supplied soups wherever needed.

The well-known Cambridge businessman, Mr. J. Frank Facey.

By mid-October, the peak of the epidemic had passed. The city lifted the ban on meetings and allowed shops to reopen. The outdoor camp at Merrill was dismantled, although the hospital remained open until November 6. Schools resumed on October 28. From October 4 through the end of 1918, 3,014 cases of influenza were reported; by the end of February 1919, Cambridge had lost 688 residents to influenza and to flu complicated by pneumonia.

On November 11, 1918, the Great War came to an end, and Cambridge celebrated.

Wild and Hilarious Scenes Enacted on Monday on Receipt of News of the Signing of the Armistice

Harvard Botanic Garden – A Lost Landscape

Harvard Botanic Garden in 1873 atlas showing arrangement of walkways and buildings. (Atlas of the City of Cambridge, G.M. Hopkins & Co., Philadelphia, PA, 1873)

From the early 1800s to the 1940s a botanical garden occupied 7 acres at the corner of Linnaean and Garden streets. Now the site of an apartment complex aptly named Botanic Gardens, Harvard Botanic Garden was one of the earliest botanical gardens in the United States comprising plants from around the world as well as indigenous trees, shrubs, and herbaceous plants that were considered “worthy of attention, as being useful in domestic economy, in the arts, or in medicine.” [1] It is also associated with Asa Gray (1810-1888), a prominent botanist, educator, and writer known for his work to help unify the taxonomic knowledge of plants in North America.

View of American persimmon tree (Diospyrus virginiana). (CHC staff)

The only remaining evidence of the botanic garden landscape are several specimen trees including, among others, ginkgo (Gingko biloba), American persimmon (Diospyrus virginiana), amur cork tree (Philodendron Amurense), tea crabapple (Malus hupehensis), and pagoda tree (Styphnolobium japonicum). The history of Harvard Botanic Garden is complex and associated with numerous individuals who have contributed to the science of botany. This post offers a glimpse into the history of the landscape itself that was not only a center of academic study and research but also a popular public green space.

An early conceptual layout designating areas for plant displays, greenhouses, cold frames, hot house, areas for trees and shrubs, and housing. (Harvard University Archives)

The layout of the garden was conceived by Gabriel Thouin, a landscape designer and gardener at the Jardins des Plantes in Paris. William Dandridge Peck, the first professor of natural history at Harvard and charged with starting the botanical garden, met with Thouin on his tour of Europe’s gardens. The resulting scheme consisted of concentric planting beds radiating out from a central pool. The design was later modified to work with the site’s topography, creating formal display beds in the southern portion and locating utilitarian functions to the north, with buildings and greenhouses situated on a terrace overlooking the garden. Peck supervised the construction of the garden and oversaw its management until his untimely death in 1822. Thomas Nuttall, an English naturalist and explorer, then served as curator until 1834 when he resigned to go on an expedition along the Oregon Trail.

In 1842, Asa Gray was appointed the Fisher Professorship of Natural History chair and oversaw the botanic garden. Gray appealed to his American colleagues to send him seeds and specimens from all over North America to grow at the garden and exchange them with European botanists. During his tenure, a new greenhouse and conservatory were constructed as well as a building to house the herbarium he was organizing. In 1871, Gray inaugurated the first Harvard Summer School course with instruction in botany in order to take advantage of the climate to study plants outside. Summer classes in natural history, chemistry, and geology soon followed, and continue today.

View of central pool and display beds from the main walkway below the terrace in 1874. To the right, a wood stockade fence enclosed the property. (Harvard University Archives, http://id.lib.harvard.edu/images/olvwork416612/catalog

Gray retired in 1872 from teaching and managing the botanic garden to focus on his work at the herbarium. That same year the culture of woody plants was transferred to the newly established Arnold Arboretum in Jamaica Plain. Harvard appointed Charles Sprague Sargent, a botanist and graduate of Harvard, as Director of both the botanic garden and the arboretum. At the botanic garden he continued specimen exchanges, overseeing the garden’s upkeep, and providing plants for the botany classes. In 1876, due to the limited amount of space, Sargent received approval from the College to plant a small arboretum on the grounds around the Harvard Observatory, located across Garden Street, featuring a representative collection of mostly North American species. Sargent still planted specimen trees within the garden to test their hardiness such as American beech (Fagus grandifolia), European beech (Fagus sylvatica), tulip (Liriodendron sp.), cucumber tree (Magnolia acuminata), black walnut (Juglans nigra), butternut (Juglans cinereal), cork elm (Ulmus thomasii), and a variety of maple trees. He also oversaw the installation of a large collection of ferns in the western portion of the site.

As new plants were being introduced into the garden, duplicate trees and shrubs were removed to make more room available. Existing plots were cleared, graded, and laid out in a series of long and narrow beds lined with grass paths. Labeled plantings were organized in botanical order according to a prescribed plan. The ground under the shade of large trees was used for rockeries for spring plants that would bloom before the trees were fully leaved and created too much shade. There were two small ponds for the cultivation of aquatics, and a spring at the corner of Linnaean and Garden Street served as a drinking fountain and provided moisture to a bog garden beside it.

Although the garden was primarily devoted to scientific plant displays, exhibits were created to appeal to the general public, including one display featuring plants referenced in Shakespeare’s works. Other beds displayed native plants that flourished during the time of Harvard’s founding, and another bed featured plants mentioned in poems by Virgil.

George Goodale, who succeeded Sargent in 1879, created an exhibit of economic plants, such as those utilized for textiles, dyes, tanning materials, and drugs. Additional trees were distributed throughout the grounds at this time including Austrian pine (Pinus nigra), tulip (Liriodendron tulipifera), American beech (Fagus grandifolia), and yellowwood (Cladrastis kentukea).

Site plan of both the botanic garden and observatory prepared in1888 from surveys by Harvard engineering students. (Harvard University Archives)

Alterations in the garden in the early 1890s included filling in the large water lily pond near Raymond Street because the water level could no longer be maintained after the construction of a sewer. Some of the original greenhouses were also replaced with a new iron-frame greenhouse. Plants for botany classes at Radcliffe were now being cultivated at the garden, and Cambridge public schools were invited to use plants from the garden for their classes.

View of the Garden House from within the formal display area in 1893. (Harvard University Archives, http://id.lib.harvard.edu/images/olvsite18782/urn-3:GSD.loeb:111447/catalog)

In the early 1900s, plant displays along the embankment below the terrace contained white arabis (Arabis caucasica), phlox (Phlox paniculata), English daisies (Bellis perennis), grape hyacinths (Muscari armeniacum), saxifrage (Saxafraga tridactylites), dog-tooth violets (Erythronium dens-canis), yellow daffodils (Narcissus), and a variety of tulips imported from Holland. Landscape architecture students were offered opportunities to gain practical experience by designing planting plans for discrete areas of the garden that were installed by garden staff. In 1910, the Garden House was sold and moved to 88 Garden Street.

In 1917, the border below the terrace was replanted to illustrate the Engler system of plant taxonomy for botany classes. During World War I, residents installed vegetable gardens under the guidance of the head gardener on land adjoining the botanic garden. A model vegetable garden was also installed on the grounds of the botanic garden near the greenhouses for residents to study and imitate.

In 1923, Stephen F. Hamblin, an assistant professor of landscape architecture and horticulture instructor at Harvard, was appointed Director of the garden. The university also formed a visiting committee to plan for the potential use of the garden as a testing ground for all hardy herbs suitable for culture in the region. The collection had 2,000 species, and the committee sought to increase the number to 6,000 and grow 1,000 annuals as well.

Hamblin wrote an article for Landscape Architecture Magazine with this plan illustrating existing and future plant displays. “THE PLAN FOR THE HARVARD UNIVERSITY BOTANIC GARDEN.” Landscape Architecture Magazine 14, no. 3 (1924): 180-85. http://www.jstor.org/stable/44661894.

Hamblin proposed modifying the grounds utilizing existing trees and shrubs as a background for the herb plantings or provide shade to those in need of it. He also suggested planting annuals in the beds around the central lily pond, installing orchids and ferns in the shade of a large group of trees, planting lilies in a “wild garden” arrangement under tall trees, and placing irises in a long border below the terrace. Additional proposed elements included breeding of new varieties and hybrids of herbs, breeding hardy rose varieties, and planting of American wildflowers.

View of botanic garden with terrace overlooking display beds in the mid 1920s. A display of irises lined the walkway below the terrace. The Herbarium is at the right. (Harvard University Archives, HUA HUV 1200)

Unfortunately, Hamblin was not able to fully realize his ambitious plan. In 1929, Harvard’s administration decided that due to chronic inadequate funding, the botanic garden would cease to function as an ornamental horticulture display area and focus solely on scientific study. Harvard President A. Lawrence Lowell later announced that the management of the botanic garden would be transferred to the Botany Department and he named professor Robert H. Woodworth as Hamblin’s replacement. Hamblin went on to establish and oversee the Lexington Botanic Garden in Massachusetts. Plant collections deemed no longer relevant at the botanic garden were transferred to Lexington, including a rose collection with the understanding that should the Arnold Arboretum start to cultivate roses, cuttings would be provided. In addition, beds west of the herbarium containing the collection of the American Iris Society were cleared after specimens were taken by the Society or transferred to Lexington.

The continued lack of funds and gardening staff also resulted in neglected grounds that were no longer a desirable place to visit. Although the greenhouses were still used to provide plant material for classrooms and research, they were in such a state of disrepair that it was decided to remove them and transfer selected plant material to other facilities. Outdoor plants continued to be maintained for experimental plantings. Prior to demolition, a large shipment of living plants was shipped to the Atkins Institute in Cuba. Remaining plant material was transferred to greenhouses at Harvard’s Biological Laboratory and the Bussey Institution. Other stock was presented to the Massachusetts State College, the Boston Teachers College, Wellesley College, and Boston Parks Department.

In 1937, Harvard collaborated with the Herb Society of America to plant an herb garden on the site of the demolished greenhouse complex, highlighting plants adaptable to New England conditions. The garden staff would care for the collection, but development would be sponsored by the Society. Initially, an evergreen hedge was planted, and a brick retaining wall and paths were constructed. Fourteen planting beds were laid out, and a wrought iron armillary sphere[2] on a brick pedestal was placed in the center. Three benches, each flanked by four-foot rosemary bushes, were installed along with four large flowering trees. Beds were then filled with herbs donated by members of the New England Group of the Herb Society of America.

In 1945, the City of Cambridge considered acquiring the botanic garden site through imminent domain to construct temporary housing for returning veterans. In response, rare plant species were transferred to the Arnold Arboretum. The City did not follow through, but the Director of the garden at the time, Elmer Merrill, suggested that the property be sold or used by Harvard to develop a housing program. Harvard did not reach a decision until 1948, when the demand for housing became acute. The university proceeded to construct new residences on the botanic garden site for faculty as well as returning servicemen consisting of 117 single-family, duplex, and apartment units and was completed in 1949. Today, the landscape of the Botanic Gardens Apartments still features some wonderful and unusual mature specimen trees from its storied past.

View of one of the courtyards at Botanic Gardens Apartments with curving walkway perhaps a nod to the curving walkways and plant beds of the botanic garden. (CHC staff)
This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is courtyard.jpg
Hints of the botanic garden landscape can still be found including some distinctive trees, left to right, umbrella pine, ginkgo, and dawn sequoia. (CHC staff)

[1] William Dandridge Peck, A Catalog of American and Foreign Plants Cultivated in the Botanic Garden, Cambridge, Massachusetts, (Cambridge, MA: Hilliard & Metcalf, 1818), introductory page.

[2] model of objects in the sky consisting of a spherical framework of rings, centered on Earth or the Sun, that represent lines of celestial longitude and latitude and other astronomically important features

For additional information, please see resources below:

“The Botanic Garden,” Cambridge Chronicle, Volume XI, Number 44, November 1, 1856.

“New Building at the Botanic Garden,” Cambridge Chronicle, April 2, 1864.

“Harvard Botanic Garden, A Beautiful Home of Floriculture Open to the Public,” Cambridge Chronicle, March 30, 1878.

Gamwell, Edward F. “The Harvard Botanical Garden,” Cambridge Chronicle, June 17, 1898.

“Harvard Botanic Garden,” Cambridge Chronicle, May 14, 1904.

Thomas, Richard. “Remember A Lost Garden.” Cambridge Chronicle, Volume 154, No. 47, September 27, 2000.

Goodale, George Lincoln. “The Botanic Garden at Cambridge.” The Harvard Register, Vol.1, no. 1, Cambridge, MA: Moses King, 1881.

Goodwin, Joan W. “A Kind of Botanic Mania.” Arnoldia, Vol. 56, n. 5, 1996-97, pp. 17-24.

Graustein, Jeannette E. “Natural History at Harvard College, 1788-1842.” Proceedings of the Cambridge Historical Society, Volume 38, 1959-1960.

Hamblin, Stephen F. “In Cause of Horticulture, Botanic Garden of Harvard Performs Valuable Public Service.” Parks and Recreation, Vol. VIII, No. 1, The Institute at Minot, SD: September – October, 1924.

Hamblin, Stephen F. “Plan for Harvard Botanic Garden.” Landscape Architecture Magazine, American Society of Landscape Architects, Vol. 14, No. 3, April 1924, pp. 180-185.

Hammond, Charles A. “The Botanic Garden in Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1805-1834.” The Herbarist, Volume 53 (1987), Concord, MA: The Herb Society of America.

Harvard University Catalog, 1903-1904. Cambridge, MA: published by the University.

Ingersoll, Ernest. “Harvard’s Botanic Gardens and Its Botanists.” Century City Magazine, Vol. XXXII, No. 2, June 1886.

Peck, William Dandridge. A Catalog of American and Foreign Plants Cultivated in the Botanic Garden, Cambridge Massachusetts. Cambridge, MA: Hilliard & Metcalfe for University Press, 1818.

Meet Phebe Mitchell Kendall of Nantucket and Cambridge

Mitchell House
The Mitchell Family House. The roof deck is a later addition.

The Mitchell Family of Nantucket

In celebration of Preservation Month, Preservation Massachusetts has announced fourteen projects that will receive grants for exterior restoration of their historic properties. The Maria Mitchell Association, which owns and operates the 1790 Maria Mitchell House on Nantucket, was awarded an $8,250 grant. The house has been a museum since 1903.

Maria Mitchell (1818-1889) was the third of ten children, half girls, half boys. Her sister Phebe, ten years her junior, lived and worked in Cambridge. Maria was America’s first professional female astronomer. The Mitchell house website, https://www.mariamitchell.org, has more information on the family and a wonderful collection of photographs.

Phebe Mitchell

Phebe Mitchell was born on Nantucket on February 23, 1828, into a Quaker family. William and Lydia (Coleman) Mitchell believed in equality in education, and all the children (Phebe was the seventh of ten) were educated in public schools and at home.

AtheneumHistory_Page_04[1]
The original Nantucket Atheneum. Initially open to members only, the Atheneum offered lectures and meeting space, as well as a small lending library. Many of the notable speakers–Ralph Waldo Emerson, Henry David Thoreau, and the education reformer Horace Mann–dined with the Mitchells. Photo courtesy Nantuck Atheneum.
AtheneumHistory_Page_11[1]
The second Nantucket Atheneum, 1848. The original building had burned in an 1847 fire; all books and many records were lost, but Maria Mitchell had compiled a catalogue of holdings. She became the institute’s librarian and relied on her list to rebuild the collections. Photo courtesy Nantucket Atheneum.
Lydia Mitchell was a librarian and often brought books home for the family to read. Phebe described her mother as:

a woman of strong character, very dignified, honest almost to an
extreme. … She … kept a close watch over her children, was clear-
headed … and an indefatigable worker. It was she who looked out
for the education of the children and saw what their capacities were.

Her father, “a man of great suavity and gentleness,” was a teacher, a banker, and a well-known amateur astronomer.

Bank-of-America-Nantucket-1-1024x683[1]
Nantucket Pacific National Bank. Photo Bank of America
For almost twenty-five years Mr. Mitchell was the cashier at Nantucket’s Pacific National Bank, where he kept a suite of rooms in which the family occasionally lived. He constructed a small observatory on the bank’s flat roof, and everyone took part in watching the sky and calculating complex astronomical formulae. One night in 1847, Maria (allegedly escaping a dull dinner party) went up to look at the stars and discovered a comet, “Miss Mitchell’s comet.”

Phebe and Joshua Kendall

Phebe Mitchell and Joshua Kendall were married on Nantucket on September 14, 1854; the groom had been born in Cambridge in 1828 and graduated from Harvard College in 1853. The couple moved to Meadville, Pennsylvania, where Joshua served as the second president of Meadville Theological Seminary, which was then a Unitarian institution. Their only child, William Manning,, was born in 1856 when Joshua was the master of a private school in Jamaica Plain, Massachusetts. In 1860 he became the chief academic officer, or principal, of the Rhode Island State Normal School, then in Bristol; the 1860 census records Joshua, Phebe, and four-year-old Willie living in a boarding house. The state cut back funding for the school, and it was forced to close in 1864.

Kendall School, Chronicle18650121
First notice of Joshua Kendall’s new school. Note the impressive references!Cambridge Chronicle, January 18, 1865

Joshua moved his family to Cambridge, bought the house at 123 Inman Street, and opened Kendall’s Day and Family School, a private preparatory school for boys, at 13 Appian Way. In 1906 the family took up room in the school.

The 1878 Total Eclipse of the Sun

Phebe and her sister Maria, who had become Vassar College’s first astronomy professor in 1865, visited frequently and wrote often; the three Kendalls and Maria travelled together in Europe four times in the early 1870s. In 1878 Maria invited Phebe to come with her to Colorado to observe a total eclipse of the sun that would be best viewed from sites along the spine of the Rocky Mountains, from southern Wyoming Territory through Colorado to Texas. Professor Mitchell, Mrs. Mitchell, four Vassar graduates, and their equipment traveled by train to Denver.American Eclipse cover

David Baron, a science journalist, chronicles the eclipse excitement that swept across the United States in American Eclipse: A Nation’s Epic Race to Catch the Shadow of the Moon and Win the Glory of the World (2017).

Astronomers and their assistants vied for the best viewing spots. The Mitchell crew arrived at their site with little time to spare.

 

Maria Mitchell chose for her observation post … a hill on the edge
of [Denver], just beyond the reach of suburban development. …
Once there, the Vassar party had no time to make elaborate
preparations. The women set out wooden chairs, erected a small
tent for shade, and mounted their three telescopes on tall tripods. (Mitchell had  brought … the same telescope she had used … to
discover her famous comet.) The view east offered an endless,
empty expanse of plains. To the west lay Denver and the Rockies
behind it. Immediately to the south sat a three-story brick building topped by a gabled roof and an ornate cross. It was St. Joseph’s Home,
a Catholic hospital operated by the Sisters of Charity of Leavenworth, Kansas. The nuns, … spying the astronomers in dresses, came over to tea.

12-Colorado-Eclipse_-18781[1]

Maria Mitchell, her crew, and their equipment. The individuals are not identified, but Phebe may be pictured. Photo courtesy Maria Mitchell Association.

The Cambridge School Committee

33-Phebe-Mitchell-Kendall1[1]

In 1879 the Massachusetts General Court enacted legislation giving women the right to vote in school committee elections. That year, Phebe Mitchell Kendall and Sarah Sprague Jacobs became the first women elected to the Cambridge School Committee. Mrs. Kendall served for fourteen years, advocating for equality of education in elementary schools. A longtime member of the Cambridge Women’s Suffrage League, she served as its president for many years. She resigned from the school committee in 1894 to concentrate on organizing and editing Maria’s personal papers. Maria Mitchell: Life, Letters and Journals was published in 1896.

 

kendall

Legacy

Phebe Mitchell Kendall died in June 1907. The Cambridge newspapers all published laudatory encomiums, including a letter in the Tribune from “one who knew her.”

 

 

Joshua Kendall died in February 1913. William Mitchell Kendall (Willie) enjoyed a successful career at the distinguished New York architectural firm, McKim, Mead & White.

The Cambridge Visiting Nursing Association

In honor of National Nurses Week, today we are sharing the story of the Cambridge Visiting Nursing Association (CVNA), once headquartered at 35 Bigelow Street. The CVNA was established in 1904 by twelve Cambridge women in response to the community’s dire need for skilled home nursing care.  As cities like Cambridge grew rapidly during the late 19th and early 20th centuries, and with neighborhoods becoming denser, it became even more necessary for nurses to travel to individuals to provide healthcare – especially at a time when most healthcare was provided in the home.  An article in the Cambridge Chronicle states that the CVNA started when “a few ladies of old Cambridge supported a nurse who visited the very poor.”

80364343_2858127020874292_6234015197577609216_n
“On this day in 1922, the Cambridge VNA kicked off a highly successful fundraising campaign for home health care. Nurses gathered in front of the agency’s 35 Bigelow St., Cambridge, office for this photo.” Caption and image used with courtesy of VNA Care’s Facebook page, 1/16/2020.

During the CVNA’s first year, $5000 was raised to provide for the salary of three visiting nurses to make house calls to Cambridge residents, and for the fitting up of a nurses residence. From 1904-1908, the CVNA took quarters at 35 and 48 Bigelow Street, where the first two or three nurses employed were housed. By 1906 there were seven or eight nurses in residence, and in 1908, the CVNA purchased the entire home at 35 Bigelow for their official use. They remained headquartered there until 1987, when they relocated to 186 Alewife Brook Parkway. In 1995 the CVNA merged with VNA North Shore and the parent companies of Visiting Nurse Associates to create the VNA Care Network, “a nonprofit home health care, palliative care, hospice, and wellness provider serving more than 200 communities in Eastern and Central Massachusetts.”

PanasonicMECH=KV-S7075C SIDE=F
From the CVNA Seventh Annual Report, 1911.

From the beginning, the CVNA worked with people of all ages, though in its earlier days the nurses were chiefly involved with pre-natal care and home-births, instruction in infant care, and the treatment of tuberculosis, as well as polio and influenza. The CVNA supervisor would assign each nurse to a different case or neighborhood, discussing cases and patient plans with them.

Tribune19200214-01.2.98-a2-292w
Call for nurses – Cambridge Chronicle, February 14, 1920.

vnacaretwitter
Educational lantern slide, used with courtesy of the VNA Care Twitter account.

By the 1920s the CVNA collaborated with the Cambridge Anti-Tuberculosis Association in maintaining a health center at the Thorndike School in East Cambridge. The center offered a wide range of services, including “a nurse who gives all of her time to the district, a children’s clinic…a posture clinic…and an evening health clinic for adults.” The center also offered nutrition and hygiene classes, “training girls in the care of their younger brothers and sisters,” classes in physical exercise, mothers’ meetings, “and moving pictures and lantern-slide lectures on health subjects.”

Chronicle19200717-01.2.98-a2-295w
Cambridge Chronicle, Aug. 17, 1920

The CVNA also participated in numerous citywide activities and programs, such as educational health exhibits at the YMCA and plays put on by local school children centered around health lessons.

Chronicle19381222-01.2.89-a5-488w
“Visiting Nursing Association Makes 16,000 Visits Yearly.” Cambridge Chronicle, December 22, 1938.

As the needs of the community and healthcare delivery changed, the CVNA expanded their services to aid with the elderly and hospice services, and later added therapists, home health aides, social workers, and office personnel to their staff as well as the visiting nurses.

Chronicle19710506-01.2.21-a5-578w

Chronicle19710506-01.2.21-a6-568w
Cambridge Chronicle, May 6, 1971

In 1971 it was reported that the CVNA made 19,647 visits to 987 patients of all ages that year. They had 29 nurses on staff and worked alongside doctors and 35 other health services, including the Boston Visiting Nursing Association. The CVNA also provided disaster nursing relief alongside the Red Cross and were major caregivers during the HIV/AIDS epidemic.

Thank you to all nurses and caregivers!

vnatwitter
Cambridge visiting nurses biking to patients’ homes in 1974, used with courtesy of VNA Care’s Facebook page, May 3, 2018.

About 35 Bigelow Street:

98
35 Bigelow Street today. Cambridge Property Database.

A three-story mansard style house with a handsome side porch/piazza, built in 1869. In 1908 there was a first-floor addition built for the CVNA, followed by a second-floor addition in 1916 by the firm of Howe & Manning. In 1927 the brick garage was built for the CVNA and was changed to a two-story dwelling in 1985, now 35r Bigelow. Today the home is divided into condos.

 

Sources:

VNA Care, vnacare.org as well as their Twitter and Facebook accounts

CHS Proceedings, v. 18, 1925

Numerous articles from the Cambridge Chronicle, particularly 7/17/1920 and 3/28/1991

For photographs of other Cambridge community nurses, check out the Benedict Daniels Scrapbook on our Flickr page.

Modern Monday – Botanic Gardens Apartments

Botanic Garden Apts HUA IMG_20160229_123646
Architects’ rendering of new residential development at the corner of Garden and Linnaean streets, 1948.

In 1949, to meet the acute demand for housing, Harvard University constructed new residences for faculty as well as returning WWII servicemen. According to an article in the April 29, 1948 issue of the Cambridge Chronicle, the primary purpose of the new residences was “to reduce the pressure on Harvard faculty and families and on veterans living and working in the community.” Located at the corner of Linnaean and Garden streets, the site had been the University’s botanic garden and herbarium under the direction of the botany department. In addition to its primary role as a scientific collection, the garden had also been a very popular public green space.

6.243 Botanic Garden Apts
View of two-story apartment building and walkway with stone retaining wall, and mature trees.

The planned community consisted of 117 single-family, duplex, and apartment units. The architects, Des Granges and Steffian, integrated their plan with the existing terrain and preserved landscape features where possible. Along the site’s northern boundary, single-family and semi-detached houses adjoined Gray Gardens East, while two-story buildings along Linnaean and Garden streets created a transition to the higher density three-story apartment blocks that occupied the center of the complex. Following old garden paths, two new streets were constructed for the development, both named after past curators of the herbarium, Benjamin Robinson and Merritt Fernald.

bg apartment brochure floorplan
Original brochure highlighting typical 2-bedroom apartment layout.

botanic_ext_01_Detail Wide_0

The multi-unit buildings were organized around courtyards incorporating existing mature trees. Due to the sloping site, three-story buildings transition to two stories on the south sides of the courtyards, so they receive ample sunlight even in winter. Mortared stone and concrete retaining walls and concrete steps negotiated levels within the varied topography. Buildings were constructed of red brick with flat roofs, simple squared-off cornices, and casement windows. The main entrances were designed as focal points with flat-roofed canopies below projecting two-story bay windows. More extensive use of glass flanking the entry door and extending up the bay windows was in contrast to the more austere and opaque brick facades.

bg apt 02
View of one of the courtyards.

bg apt 01
View of courtyard with mature multi-stemmed tree and building with altered entrance including added columns and new canopy.

In the 1990s, Blackstone Block Architects was commissioned to renovate the complex including  new accessible entrances, signage, outdoor seating, brick sidewalks along Fernald Drive, and new plantings.  The residences remain under Harvard University Housing.

bg apt 03
View from Fernald Drive.

Sources

Cambridge Chronicle, April 29, 1948.

Building Old Cambridge, Susan E. Maycock and Charles M. Sullivan, 2016.