Cambridge Designers: William Everett Chamberlin

We are starting a new series on designers (architects, builders, landscape architects, and others) who have had a lasting impact on Cambridge’s built environment. For our first post in this series, we are featuring a lesser-known architect who lived and worked right here in Cambridge, William Everett Chamberlin.

William E. Chamberlin, 1907 Class Book courtesy of MIT Libraries

William Everett Chamberlin (1856-1911) was born in Cambridge on June 23, 1856, to Ann Maria Stimson (1822-1907) and Daniel Upham Chamberlin (1824-1898), a prominent Cambridgeport hardware dealer and president of the Cambridgeport Savings Bank. William Chamberlin (sometimes spelled Chamberlain) attended Cambridge public schools before enrolling at MIT, where he majored in Architecture.

William E. Chamberlin, Class of 1877 photograph, courtesy of MIT Libraries.

After graduating from MIT in 1877, the 22-year-old was hired as a draftsman by the esteemed firm of Sturgis and Brigham, architects in Boston. In February 1879, William moved to New York City, and began working as a draftsman at the internationally known firm of McKim, Mead, and White (MMW). Upon arriving in New York, William was quickly overwhelmed. Thinking there was a great deal he hadn’t learned, he was given permission by the firm to travel Europe for over two years to study in the Ecole des Beaux Arts, Paris, and to hone his drawing skills while travelling about the continent. He returned to the office of McKim, Mead & White in New York in early 1882, as the firm was receiving lucrative commissions with its Gilded Age clientele.

Sketch at Chaumont-Sur-Loire by William E. Chamberlin. Published in Catalogue of the architectural exhibition, Boston Society of Architects (1886).

Within a few months of arriving in the United States, William quit his job as a draftsman at MMW and returned to Cambridge, seemingly due to poor health – an issue which plagued him his entire life. Later publications explained that Chamberlin suffered from spinal troubles, which progressed enough that it left him confined to a wheelchair for much of his adulthood.

After a season of rest, William opened his own architecture office in downtown Boston, commuting from his parent’s house in Central Square. Recounting the early days of his own practice to former classmates in 1885, he sarcastically wrote: “I have started in business for myself here in Boston, though somehow or other, there don’t seem to be many ‘riche amateurs’ who want to build big ‘musees’ in parks as there used to be in the school programs. Still, I manage to get three meals a day, Voila”!

While Chamberlin joked about a slow start to his office, one of his earliest commissions was among his most important. In 1883, he designed an administration building and hospital wings for the new Cambridge Hospital (renamed Mount Auburn Hospital in 1947) in Cambridge. The building consisted of a main building of three stories and basement, which housed all departments of the hospital, including private rooms and two one-story wards, the whole forming three sides of a hollow square, with the opening toward the south and the river. Chamberlin worked closely with Dr. Morrill Wyman (1812-1903), an expert on the ventilation of sickrooms and public buildings and first president of the hospital, to orient the buildings facing the Charles River to maximize sun-exposure for south facing rooms and provide the full influence of southwestern breezes in the summer. Now known as the Parson’s Building (named after Emily Elizabeth Parsons a Civil War nurse who helped establish the hospital), Chamberlin’s first major commission in Cambridge set-off a prominent, yet largely overlooked career.

After receiving just a few commissions while running his own practice, Chamberlin entered into a business partnership with architect William Marcy Whidden (1857-1929). Whidden was a former classmate of Chamberlin, who’s career path mirrored much of his. They both graduated from MIT in architecture in 1877, they both studied at the Ecole des Beaux Arts in Paris, and both worked at the office of McKim, Mead & White. Whidden left MMW in 1885, when propositioned with the idea of running his own practice with Chamberlin. The duo established the firm of Chamberlin & Whidden that year.

The firm, led by a pair of thirty-year-old architects, was hired to design buildings all over the Boston area. Due to this success, they hired other young, promising architects to assist with drafting. One of those hires was Henry Bacon, who briefly worked for Chamberlin and Whidden before joining McKim, Mead & White. Locally, Henry Bacon could be known as the designer for the steps and walls of the Longfellow Monument in Longfellow Park, but he is best known for his design of the Lincoln Memorial in Washington, D.C. (built 1915–1922), which was his final project. Within the first few years, the firm of Chamberlin and Whidden saw a lot of activity, including furnishing designs for a six-story commercial building in Boston in the Romanesque Revival style. Their major type of commission, however, was expensive, single-family suburban housing.

Stores on South Street, Boston, Mass. Featured in American Architect and Building News, February 1887.

The firm built beautiful homes including one on Highland Street for Robert Noxon Toppan (1836-1901) and his wife, Sarah Moody Cushing. The Colonial Revival style house was built in 1886 and is one of the earliest houses in Cambridge of the style, setting trends for its neighbors. The brick Toppan House exhibits a large Palladian window at the façade, with a rounded center bay and a full-length piazza overlooks the gently terraced landscape towards Brattle Street at the rear.

House at Cambridge, Mass. Featured in American Architect and Building News, February 1887.

When a design competition was announced for the new Cambridge City Hall, a few local firms were asked to submit designs following benefactor Frederick H. Rindge’s strict requirements. The advisory design committee suggested that Peabody & Stearns, Van Brunt & Howe, Longfellow, Alden & Harlow, John Lyman Faxon, and Chamberlin and Whidden all submit designs for consideration. Chamberlin and Whidden proposed a stately, symmetrical building with a strong Romanesque emphasis and a central clock tower, capped by a belfry and cupola. Their design was not accepted by Rindge, who selected Longfellow, Alden & Harlow instead. Undeterred, the young firm persevered.

Chamberlin & Whidden proposal for Cambridge City Hall, 1888. American Architect & Building News, June 1888.

A second time, Chamberlin and Whidden submitted in a design competition for the English High School in Cambridge, and won the design competition in 1889, securing that job. It would be their final project together in Cambridge. Their plans for the new High School called for a three-story masonry building of stone on the first floor with light-red brick above. The building was long and narrow, giving each classroom ample natural light and ventilation. Articles mentioned that there was little ornamentation as “the desire of all concerned was to construct a simple and dignified building expressive of its serious purpose”. The building was demolished in 1938 for the consolidated Cambridge High and Latin School.

English High School, photographed 1908. Detroit Publishing Company.

By 1890, William Whidden had moved west to Oregon and established his own firm. William promoted architect William Downes Austin (1856-1944) to partner of the firm, renaming it Chamberlin & Austin. The new firm kept busy with a steady stream of commissions, but it was clear Chamberlin’s health was preventing him from actively seeking out new projects as he once did. Many of the designs the firm completed as Chamberlin & Austin appear to have been from previous clients, showing their trust in Chamberlin’s quality designs.

One such projects was commissioned by Henry Endicott, whos large home at 151 Brattle Street was designed by Henry Bacon Jr. while working under William Chamberlin in 1888. Two years later in 1890, Endicott returned to Chamberlin to design a smaller residence on the newly laid out Brewster Street, at the rear of the Brattle Street property, for his daughter and son-in-law. The second house, much smaller in size, showcases Chamberlin’s attention to detail with the saw-tooth cut shingle and recessed porch at the entrance and gentle undulating form with continuous shingled siding.

In 1891, William Chamberlin married Emily Douglass Abbott (1858-1916). The couple acquired a house lot on Clinton Street, at the rear of Emily’s father George Abbott’s residence on Harvard Street. That year, William designed his new house on Clinton Street and a renovation for his father’s new home on Harvard Street. The three houses were all direct neighbors. William Chamberlin’s new home on Clinton Street was the first of his own, after decades of boarding with his father and mother in Central Square. For his own house, William designed a modest, 1½ -story structure with prominent gambrel roof. The house, while altered, exhibits Chamberlin’s eclectic sense of design, which often blends styles into a single composition. William and Emily never had children. One year later, William D. Austin left the firm to partner with Frederick W. Stickney forming Stickney & Austin.

William E. Chamberlin entered a semi-retirement due to his worsening health, which plagued him most of his life but could never fully step away from his passion for design. When he heard about the death of his beloved former professor at MIT, Eugene Letang in 1891, Chamberlin designed a memorial tablet of bronze set into a carved marble surround. This marker still stands in the Boston Public Library, Copley Square branch location. With this work, Chamberlin showed his skill beyond designing buildings. It is possible that he was the designer of many of his family memorial stones in the family plot at Mount Auburn Cemetery.

Eugène Létang tablet designed by W. E. Chamberlin. Ca. 1905 photograph, Boston Public Library collections.

He was hired again by the Cambridge Hospital (now Mount Auburn Hospital) in 1896, designing a Nurse’s Residence just steps away from the Administration Building and Hospital wings he designed over ten years prior. His design for the Nurse’s Residence, like nearly all his work, blends multiple styles effortlessly into a single composition. The brick building displays strong Classical features including the central columned portico and the belt course above the second story windows which reads as a frieze band with ocular windows. Soon after in 1898, he designed the Cambridge Homes for Aged People at 360 Mt. Auburn Street with former partner Stickney and Austin.

Nearly a decade later in 1904, Chamberlin and Boston architect Clarence Blackall completed designs for the new Cambridgeport Savings Bank (where his late father once served as president) in Central Square, Cambridge. The building is perhaps Chamberlin’s most recognizable and stately extant design where he could show-off his architectural versatility. The Cambridgeport Savings Bank is a monumentally scaled limestone-clad structure with a façade dominated by recessed central bays behind an engaged Corinthian portico. The ornate stone parapet which once capped the building was replaced in the 1950s. The Cambridgeport Savings Bank building is Chamberlin’s last known work in Cambridge before his death.

Cambridgeport Savings Bank Building, 689 Mass. Ave. CHC Postcard Collection.

At just 55 years old, William Everett Chamberlin died from a stroke on August 6, 1911, in Manchester Massachusetts, at his father-in-law’s summer house. When news of his passing spread, fellow members of the Boston Society of Architects memorialized of Chamberlin:

William E. Chamberlin was by nature dowered with great personal charm, a clear keen brain, debonair in its perceptions, just in its conclusions; a genius for his profession of architecture which was rare; and a fresh directness of expression tempered by a delicate humor. The active use of these qualities in the work of the great marketplace was first checked and then barred to him by a disease, which prevented his working outside of his home, and for over twenty years he made that home a center of intellectual stimulus to his friends…His noble character vibrated only perfect harmonies, but, unlike the harp in the wind, in him was the soul and the strong will which decreed always, as a duty to his fellow men, that no discords should mar the beauties of this life which, in spite of one great affliction, he found and made so blessed even to the last hour.

Last known photograph of William E. Chamberlin, ca.1910

William E. Chamberlin bequeathed nearly all his sizable estate, estimated at nearly $100,000, to several Cambridge institutions. His widow, Emily D. Chamberlin, received the income from his estate during her lifetime and that after her death. After which, it was distributed in seven parts. Two-sevenths went to the Cambridge Hospital, two-sevenths to the Cambridge Homes for Aged People, and one-seventh each to the Avon Home, the Holy Ghost Hospital, and to the Department of Architecture at MIT, which he remained engaged with throughout his life. Chamberlin’s legacy has lived on not only through his extant buildings, but his generosity, in the William Everett Chamberlain (sic) Prize for achievement in design at MIT and his generous gifts to Cambridge institutions.

William Everett Chamberlin is buried at Mount Auburn Cemetery on Bellwort Path in the family plot. His monument, like many of his family members, was likely designed by himself from his Cambridge home.

William E. Chamberlin’s monument at Mt. Auburn Cemetery. Much of lettering covered by lichen.

Real Estate Revelations, Part 2: 3000 Pounds of Clay?

Oh, the sorts of properties real estate agents are asked to find!

In 1893, Ellis & Melledge received a request from sculptor George Thomas Brewster. Brewster wrote from the Mechanics Building in Boston, looking for studio space in Cambridge. His discussions about taking a studio owned by “Mr. Newell” didn’t work out because “the floor supports will not be strong enough to stand the weight of some large work that I shall want to commence soon…”

Image of George T. Brewster as it appeared in Empire State Notables, 1914.

Brewster goes on to explain: “the clay alone will weigh from 3 to 4 tons and when the plaster mould [sic] is added it will make from 1 ½ to 2 tons extra.” About Mr. Newell’s studio, he “noticed that the supports for floor at the stairs are only nailed. Even if the cross beams were set into the sils [sic] they would not be heavy enough to support my work…”

Brewster finally settled on the studio of Cambridge sculptor William Clark Noble (1858-1938) at 46 North Ave, a building that is now demolished, but would be located at present-day 1607 Mass Ave at the intersection of Everett Street. The two sculptors undoubtedly knew each other and one another’s work as they were contemporaries. Both had worked in New York and specialized in monumental bronze memorial sculpture.

Detail of 1894 G.W. Bromley and Co. Bromley Atlas showing 46 North Ave

George T. Brewster

George T. Brewster was born in Kingston, Mass and was a descendent of William Brewster, after whom Brewster, Massachusetts is named. George studied at the Normal Art School in Boston and the Ecole des Beaux in Paris, and later taught life drawing classes at the Art Students League in New York and at the Cowles Art School in Boston. Brewster was a prolific sculptor of war memorials, cemetery memorials, and portraits.

In late 1893, Brewster entered a competition to design a Civil War monument in the Forest Dale Cemetery in Malden. He won the commission, and it is likely that this was the reason he was looking for studio space in Cambridge. His winning design was of “an heroic figure of a woman who will stand as a symbol of the valor by women during the struggle for freedom.”

…the left hand grasps the now useless sword, the right holds the laurel crown ready to be set upon the head of the victors. A spiked cannon is under her left foot, a soldier’s cap and other accessories strewn about signify that war is over, that no more will the rampant hand of bitterness and death sweep over our land, that the armies have disbanded and that the spirit of woman, so sincere and earnest in the success of the sacred cause, now just as earnestly proclaims that peace is on earth and that good will must prevail towards men.”

Monumental News, July 1895

The dedication took place in Malden on Labor Day, 1894. The following year, Brewster’s plaster casts of five American poets were on display in J. F. Olsson’s art supply store in Harvard Square:

Cambridge Chronicle April 20, 1895

Other images of Brewster’s work include:

The Greek Law Giver. Image: Columbia University, Libraries Digital Collections
Close up of the top of the Fountain of Nature, Pan American Exposition, Buffalo, NY 1901. Image: https://www.tottenvillehistory.com/

William Clark Noble

Sculptor W. Clark Noble with his Lincoln the Candidate bust, August 30, 1924. Cropped from negative. National Photo Company Collection, Library of Congress.

William Clark Noble was born in Maine in 1858. Legend has it that he was inspired to become a sculptor at the age of eight after reading the life story of the Danish sculptor Berthel Thorvaldsen.[ii] Noble studied under Richard Greenough, and by 1879, when he was only 21, he had relocated in Newport, Rhode Island. There, Noble designed a statue of William Ellery Channing and the Soldier’s and Sailor’s monument. He was a busy man! In 1892, Noble opened a studio in New York.[iii]  At the same time, he had a studio in Cambridge at 46 North St. In 1893, when Brewster was trying to locate studio space, Noble’s statue of Robert Burns (destined for Rhode Island) was still at his studio on North Avenue.

Boston Globe May 22, 1892
Cambridge Tribune July 9, 1892
From “Paper on ‘Cambridge Artists’” by Miss Almira L. Hayward as published in the Cambridge Chronicle November 4, 1893
Governor Andrew Curtin (1911-13), Pennsylvania State Memorial, Gettysburg Battlefield. W. Clark Noble, Sculptor. Photographed 1914. Image: Wikipedia.
Civil War Soldiers and Sailors Monument in Congdon Park, Newport, Rhode Island. W. Clark Noble, Sculptor. Photographed ca 2004. Image: http://www.geocities.ws/leokennedy/congdon.html.

Among Noble’s most famous monumental sculptures are the Phillips Brooks Monument in New York, the Soldiers’ and Sailors’ Monument in Congdon Park, Newport, Rhode Island, the portrait bust of Revolutionary General Potter, and Napoleon Bonaparte. Noble also took on smaller commissions, one example being a portrait bust of George Washington Carver:

Patinated Copper-clad Bust of George Washington Carver, after William Clark Noble. Image: https://www.invaluable.com/
Current building at 1607 Mass Ave. Image: https://hls.harvard.edu/

Today’s post was written by CHC volunteer Kathleen Fox.


SOURCES

Catalogue of an exhibition of contemporary American sculpture held under the auspices of the National Sculpture Society; June 17-October 2, 1916. via HathiTrust.

Empire State Notables, 1914 New York, N.Y. : H. Stafford, [c1914]. Electronic reproduction. New York, N.Y.: Columbia University Libraries, 2008.

Forest Dale Cemetery GAR Monument, Massachusetts Civil War Monuments Project. https://macivilwarmonuments.com/tag/forest-dale-cemetery-gar-monument/.

Letter from George T. Brewster letter To Ellis/Melledge August 18, 1893. Ellis and Andrews Collection, Cambridge Historical Commission.

Monumental News, Vol. 7 No., 7, July 1895, pp. 419  http://quariesandbeyond.org/

Soldiers’ Monument, Malden, Massachusetts. George T. Brewster, Sculptor. In The Monumental News, vol. 7, no.7 July 1895, pp. 419. Lehman College Art Gallery.

“William Clark Noble” Invaluable. https://www.invaluable.com/artist/noble-william-clark-zueyvesacu/.


[i] https://macivilwarmonuments.com/tag/forest-dale-cemetery-gar-monument/

[ii] Lehman College Art Gallery:   https://www.lehman.edu/vpadvance/artgallery/publicart/bio/noble.html

[iii] Lehman College Art Gallery:   https://www.lehman.edu/vpadvance/artgallery/publicart/bio/noble.html

National Gardening Day: Charles Mason Hovey

Portrait of Charles Mason Hovey included in his work The Fruits of America
The Lady Sweet Apple, from The Fruits of America

Before you chomp into that next apple, pause for a moment to consider Charles Mason Hovey, Cambridge resident and world-renowned pomologist. He co-founded the American Pomological Society and wrote The Fruits of America in an effort to “reduce the chaos of names” and document consistency in naming fruits. As he was remembered:

“Horticulture on this continent is probably more indebted to him than to any living man.”
“The Gardeners’ Monthly and Horticulturist” (Meehan, 1886)

Charles M. Hovey was born on Brookline Street in Cambridge in 1810, the sixth of seven children born to Phineas Brown Hovey (1770-1852) and Sarah Stone (1769-1846). His father’s family first arrived on American shores in 1635, and six generations later Charles’ father was proprietor of a grocery store at the corner of Main and Brookline Streets and an investor in Cambridgeport properties. Phineas Sr. being one of 16 children, Charles had 15 aunts and uncles on his father’s side alone – – which may explain why there are so many Hovey’s in Cambridge. The City Directory for 1848 (the first one available digitally) lists 15 Hoveys. The family included several grocers (including Charles’ brother Josiah Dana Hovey, see below), real estate agents, fire engineers, architects, a carriage smith, and a bacon curer.

Cambridge City Directory, 1866

An earlier relative, Thomas Hovey, ran the prominent Hovey Tavern in Cambridgeport which was burned down in 1828. The lithograph below, made from a drawing Charles Mason made of the tavern, shows his considerable drafting skills:

Excerpt of print in the collection of the Boston Athenaeum

Significantly, Charles’ father also owned a large garden, running from Massachusetts avenue at Pearl Street through to Franklin Street.

C. M. Hovey’s formal education appears to have ended with his 1824 Graduation from Cambridge Academy at the age of 14. By his mid- teens he was already enthusiastically gardening in his father’s garden. He took after the 18th century taxonomist Linnaeus, with a scientific approach to his interest, keeping meticulous notes and drawings on species and varieties. He did not want for energy: by age 19 he had a strawberry collection; and by age 24 he had created the first American strawberry derived from crossing varieties. Between 1832 and 1835 he had established his nursery in Cambridge, a seed store in Boston, and the first gardening magazine in America.

HOVEY & CO.

In 1832, at the age of 22, Charles and his brother Phineas Brown Hovey, Jr., (age 29) began their nursery with the purchase of one acre of land in Cambridgeport. Eight years later in 1840 they purchased 40 more acres on Cambridge St. Charles lived next door at 381 Broadway between Fayette and what would become Maple Street. The house/cottage that stood at 381 Broadway at the time Charles Hovey lived there no longer exists. The home was torn down in 1893 to make way for a new house constructed for then-owner owner John McFarlane.

1854 Walling Map with arrow towards Hovey’s house on Broadway

The nursery was divvied up into sections with pears and other fruit trees planted along its interior “lanes.” By 1848 the property included four greenhouses, each of which were 84 feet long. The size of his nursery was so staggering it is difficult to comprehend. The Cambridge Chronicle reported “Of pear trees it shows 1000 health and beautiful specimens growing in avenues, embracing about 400 varieties; while of these trees in stocks and ready purchasers, there are about 50,000. Of peaches, there are some 8,000 trees; of apples 200 varieties, and 30,000 trees for sale; of plums nectarines, apricots, cherries, about an equal number. (July 13, 1848).

Hovey specialized in the hybridization of plants, in particular was camellias. He developed a Camellia Japonica and named it for his wife, the “Mrs. Ann Maria Hovey.”

C.japonica ‘CM Hovey’ via International Camellia Society
Hovey’s Camellia house. Image: Arnold Arboretum.

“…the whole neighborhood is scented with their odor, and an array of smaller flowering plants beautifully arranged the greenhouses and outdoors.” (Cambridge Chronicle July 13, 1848)

The Hovey strawberry, “regarded as the foundation of the New England strawberry industry” was grown on large scale until about 1890. It was “the first American strawberry variety that resulted from a planned cross, and it is an ancestor of most modern varieties.” (University of Vermont)

The Hovey’s Seedling Strawberry, from The Fruits of America (1851)

Apparently, one need not go directly to the nursery to place orders. Here is an unlikely sales agent:

Cambridge Chronicle May 6, 1847

Two years after starting the nursery, in 1834 Hovey and his brother Phineas B. (also a horticulturist) opened
A “Horticultural Seed Store” at 79 & 81 on Cornhill (previously called Market Street) in Boston. It was conveniently located just below the offices of the Mass. Horticultural Society at #81 Cornhill.

Image: Historic New England
Boston Post March 19, 1834

Eventually the store moved to 53 North Market Street, opposite Faneuil Hall:

Image: Mount Auburn Historical Collections.
Boston Evening Transcript April 6, 1865

THE MASSACHUSETTS HORTICULTURAL SOCIETY

Hovey was a regular exhibitor at the Massachusetts Horticultural Society from as early as 1831, two years after the society was founded. By 1833 he was an official member. He served on numerous committees, in particular the Committee on the Library, and won countless weekly exhibition prizes. He served as President from 1863-1867. During that time, he oversaw the construction of the new hall for the society, laying the cornerstone and dedicating it in 1865 at 100-102 Tremont Street, at the corner of Bromfield St, opposite the Granary Burying Ground:

Exterior view of Horticultural Hall, corner of Tremont Street and Bromfield Street, ca. 1880. Image: Historic New England.

PUBLICATIONS

America’s first magazine dedicated to horticulture was started by Charles and his brother Phineas Jr. “The American Gardener” appeared on the scene in 1835. Later the name charmingly changed to “The Magazine of Horticulture, Botany, and All Useful Discoveries and Improvements in Rural Affairs.” Hovey remained its editor until 1868 when it ceased publication. (Hutchinson)

Cover of “American Gardener’s Magazine and Register of Useful Discoveries and Improvements in Horticulture and Rural Affairs” (1835)

Perhaps most impressive is Hovey’s two-volume quarto, The Fruits of America, with luscious chromolithographs by William Sharp which he published between 1848-1856.

Title page of The Fruits of America, volume 1 by C.M. Hovey (published 1848-1856)
The Coe’s Golden Drop Plum from The Fruits of America
The Hovey Cherry from The Fruits of America

FAMILY LIFE

In 1835 Hovey married Ann Marie Chaponil. (1814-1871). The couple had five daughters and one son. Only three of their children survived past the age of 33. Tragedy came to Hovey’s door in the 1870’s when in quick succession he lost his wife to consumption in 1871, two daughters in 1872 (one also of consumption) and a third daughter lost to consumption in 1878. Their son followed in his father’s footsteps and became a horticulturist in California.

THE DEMISE OF THE NURSERY

After Hovey’s death, the nursery was taken over by William E. Doyle (1843-1916), Cambridge democratic politician, alderman and prominent florist in Boston. Recognizing the value of the Hovey name, he referred to Hovey in all advertising, but renamed the nursery “Doyle’s Conservatories,” which he operated at #1509 Cambridge Street until around 1914.

Cambridge Chronicle, November 2, 1889
Cambridge Chronicle December 21, 1889

Then, in the 1890’s land on Cambridge Street began to be sold off for residential development. Doyle put through Camellia Avenue on the west of the Hovey estate and Leonard Ave on the east. By 1893 he had built eight houses on Leonard Street, with ten more in the works.

Excerpt from the Cambridge Tribune May 6, 1893.

The street names Hovey, Myrtle, Magnolia and Camellia Avenues mark the neighborhood bounds of the nursery. By 1894 the site for the Holy Ghost Hospital for Incurables had already been laid out.

G. W. Bromley Map, 1894

In 1895, the Holy Ghost Hospital for Incurables was established by the sisters of Charity of Montreal, whose founder was Marguerite d’Youville.

Postcard of Holy Ghost Hospital for Incurables, published by M. C. Lane Co., Boston

The name evolved over the years to the Youville Hospital, Youville Hospital and Rehabilitation Center, and finally, in 2009, the Spaulding Hospital of Cambridge. Click here to read our blog post and learn about the history of the former Holy Ghost Hospital.

Image via C. Greene Construction

DEATH

Charles Mason Hovey died of heart disease on September 1, 1887

Engraving based on portrait by Alonzo Hartwell of Boston

He is buried in Lot 4205 on Mound Avenue in the Mt. Auburn Cemetery

Cambridge Press September 3, 1887

Hovey had been an Honorary member of the Royal Societies of London and of Edinburgh, and President of the Cambridgeport Horticultural Library Association

Excerpt from the Cambridge Chronicle November 5 1887 upon the death of Jenny Lind, two months after the death of C.M. Hovey

Today’s post was written by CHC volunteer, Kathleen Fox.


SOURCES

A Taste for Horticulture B. June Hutchinson” Arnold Arboretum
Ancestry.com
Appletons’ Cyclopædia of American Biography
Cambridge Public Library Digital Newspapers and Atlases
Friends of Mount Auburn. 2012. “Charles Mason Hovey (1810 – 1887).” Mount Auburn Cemetery (blog).
January 16, 2012.
Grubinger, Vern. n.d. “History of the Strawberry.” Uvm.Edu.
Hutchinson, B. June. 1980. “A Taste for Horticulture.” Arnoldia 40 (1): 31–48.
Kevles, Daniel J. July/August 2011. “Cultivating Art.” Smithsonian Magazine, July/August 2011.
Massachusetts Horticultural Society, and Robert Manning. 1880. History of the Massachusetts Horticultural
Society. 1829-1878. Boston, Mass.
Meehan, Thomas. 1886. The Gardeners’ Monthly and Horticulturist.
Mount Auburn Cemetery
Wikipedia
Wilson, James Grant, and John Fiske (eds). 1888. Appletons’ Cyclopædia of American Biography. New York: D. Appleton & Co.

Torn Down Tuesday: 329 Harvard Street

Welcome back to our Torn Down Tuesday series! Today, we are featuring the house that once stood at 329 Harvard Street in Mid-Cambridge.

Detail of 1886 Cambridge Hopkins Atlas

In December 1848, George Washington Whittemore (1812-1870) purchased a lot from the Francis Dana estate. The lot was situated on the north side of Harvard Street between Cotton (now Hancock) and Dana Streets and backed on Hastings (now Chatham) street. The Whittemore family was prominent in the business and cultural life of Boston and Cambridge: George W. had many business ventures and was most notably a Boston hotel proprietor. After the home was finished, George W. moved in with his wife, Synia H. (Richardson), on July 8, 1850.

Photograph c. 1865 showing house, stable, and grounds

Originally richly ornamented, this suburban house blended Italianate, Greek Revival, and Gothic details in an eclectic but picturesque and singularly harmonious manner. The house typified a trend away from the strict neo-classicism of around 1850. The house was originally remarkable for extensive use of exterior papier mâché ornament. The front and side eaves of the main block, and the cupola (measuring 8′ in diameter) were trimmed with molded papier mâché “gingerbread” mounted on wooden barge boards, until they were destroyed in an accidental fire from painter’s blow-torch in 1931. The cupola retained its trim at least as late as 1951. In its eclectic design, the house was typical of suburban residences built on Dana Hill c. 1850, when formal Greek Revival tradition was yielding to freer Italianate forms and more picturesque massing.

329 Harvard St photographed by Walker Evans, ca. 1930-31. © Walker Evans Archive, The Metropolitan Museum of Art

To enter the home from Harvard Street, one would approach the front steps: five granite risers flanked by granite plinths led to a granite stoop recessed within an open rectangular front entrance. A round-arched front doorway was deeply recessed within the stoop and sheltered by a balcony.

Entrance photographed by Jack E. Baucher (August 1964)

Inside, single-paneled pilasters with 1′-high plinths and gessoed papier mâché Greek Corinthian capitals flanked all drawing room openings and “supported” plaster entabulature.

Interior pilaster detail photographed by Jack E. Baucher (August 1964)

The original interior of the home was highly lavish and Victorian. Red flocked drawing room wallpaper with cream and gilt ground dated from 1850 and remained to the end of the Whittemore occupancy. The drawing room also had original richly-colored imported carpet, red velvet lambrequins with gilded cornices, and a set of very elaborate neo-rococo furniture inspired by Louis XV forms.

Interior of 329 Harvard St photographed by Richard Ruggles, 1937 (for D.P. Myer)

The set included two white marble-topped tables, a mirrored étagère with a low marble-topped console, and chairs, sofa and footstool upholstered in original red velvet. According to family records, the curtain cornices and furniture were made by a group of travelling Swiss artisans skilled in comp work and frame making.

Interior of 329 Harvard St photographed by Richard Ruggles, 1937 (for D.P. Myer)

Marble busts of Hiram Powers’ Persephone and the Apollo Belvedere, a plaster bust of Washington, two oval family portraits of young girls ca. 1850, an oil copy of Guido Reni’s Aurora, alabaster vases, parian ware figurines, and a multitude of bibelots (a small, decorative ornament or trinket) completed the lavish drawing room ensemble, which remained intact until 1949.

Interior of 329 Harvard St photographed by Richard Ruggles, 1937 (for D.P. Myer)

A significant modernization of the house was undertaken in 1922-23 where a coal-fired hot air heating replaced the oil-fired steam system, the flooring was updated, electric lights and a laundry room were installed, among many other amenities. The home continued to be passed down to successive Whittemores until is was sold out of family in June 1951. The house changed hands several times from 1962-1964, by which time the structure had badly deteriorated. Finally, the house was demolished in 1965 to clear site for the Dana Hill Apartments. To learn more about this building, check out yesterday’s Modern Monday Instagram post!

329 Harvard St photographed by Roger Gilman, ca. 1930s

Source: Historic American Buildings Survey (HABS) report by Dr. Bainbridge Bunting (1964)

Torn Down Tuesday: 280 Harvard Street

Happy Torn Down Tuesday! As a follow up to our Modern Monday Instagram post yesterday, today we are featuring the house that once stood at 280 Harvard Street in Mid-Cambridge.

PanasonicMECH=KV-S7075C
SIDE=F
280 Harvard St, ca 1965-66 (Photographer: B. Orr)

The February 19th, 1887 edition of the Cambridge Tribune stated that the home was commissioned by Mrs. Caroline Marshall, wife of Boston merchant Moses M. Marshall for their son, Moses Sylvester. The article included a detailed description of the house and it’s building materials:

The house is set slightly back from Harvard Street and the exterior is very handsome; a piazza extends around two sides with a tower at the corner. The brick chimney is outside and is decorated with terra cotta panels. The house is clapboard, with the exception of the tower, which is singled, and the roof is covered with Brownville slate. The windows are of plate glass, while the front door has stained glass. This front door is of cherry, which is the main material used for finish the other outside doors, however, being of pine, with five panels and raised mouldings. From the vestibule one enters a hall measuring 16×9. On the right of this hall is the parlor, finished in cherry, with a large bay window formed by the tower. Back of the parlor is the library, also finished in cherry, from which opens a well arranged conservatory.

PanasonicMECH=KV-S7075C
SIDE=F
Stairway, 280 Harvard St, ca 1965-66 (Photographer: B. Orr)

On the left of the ball, through an arch, one enters the reception hall, with stairs, the latter of cherry, with a find landing measuring 11×9. Back of the reception hall is the dining-room, while in the rear of the house are the kitchen and pantries. A pleasing feature of this house is that almost every room in it contains a bay window. On the second floor are five chambers, bath-rooms, cedar closer for furs, and on the third story two chambers, a store-room and large billiard room, measuring 32×23. The house will be tastefully furnished and will have elaborate mantels.

PanasonicMECH=KV-S7075C
SIDE=F
Mantelpiece, 280 Harvard St, ca 1965-66 (Photographer: B. Orr)

It will be completed about the end of March. The architect is Mr. G. J. Williams of Boston, and the builders, Messrs. Mead, Mason & Co. of Boston.

280 Harvard was the first residence in Cambridge designed by architect. G.J. Williams. This was one of Williams’s only single-family projects in the city, and is more stylized compared to his simpler multiple-occupancy dwellings at 86-88 Webster Ave or 62-68 Plymouth Street, designed the same year as 280 Harvard. However, the house’s design was echoed in others built in the following years on Harvard Street, such as those at 284 and 298.

PanasonicMECH=KV-S7075C
SIDE=F
284 Harvard St, ca. 1965-66 (Photographer: B. Orr)

PanasonicMECH=KV-S7075C
SIDE=F
298 Harvard St, ca. 1895

According to a piece highlighting Boston markets and their proprietors, Moses S. Marshall began working for his father’s meat market in 1878 at age 18 and by 1893 was a senior member of the firm. The company, Marshall and Taylor, operated from 28 North Faneuil Hall Market in Boston.

commonwealth_xp68kn03q_accessFull
Faneuil Hall, ca. 1860s (Boston Pictorial Archive, Boston Public Library)

Moses S. Married Grace Clark on June 18, 1884 and the couple had a daughter, Dorothy Frances, on February 8, 1889. The family attended the Austin Street Unitarian Church (demolished in 1949), and Mrs. Marshall held church sewing meetings at the family residence. After a long illness, Grace Marshall died June 26, 1903 at 42 years old. Moses Sylvester Marshall died of a cerebral hemorrhage on October 24, 1909, at 49 years old. Caroline Marshall became head of the family after the death of her son, and continued to live at 280 Harvard Street with her daughter, Ella Stimson, and three granddaughters, including Dorothy.

1888_Sanborn
Detail, 1888 Sanborn Atlas (mapjunction.com)

The house was later occupied by Suffragette Mabel A. Jones, and for many years was home to members of the Manning family. The house continued as a single-occupant dwelling, and for decades saw many residents come and go. The house was demolished in 1971 to make way for the 18-story apartment building that stands a 280 Harvard Street today. For more information on the current building, see our Instagram post from Monday, April 20th.

PanasonicMECH=KV-S7075C
SIDE=F
280 Harvard St, ca 1965-66 (Photographer: B. Orr)